Friday, 8 August 2014

Discussion on the Execution of the Critical Review: "Understanding the Genre of Wildlife Photography: what are its Values and is it Art?"

After many hours of hard work (far more than was suggested in the course notes) I submitted my critical review for Assignment 3 to my tutor on 7 August 2014. The critical review proposal can be found elsewhere in this blog: broadly speaking, I stuck to the plan outlined there. What follows are the explanatory notes that accompanied the review.

I am, first and foremost, a wildlife photographer. My interest stems from a love of wildlife that I developed as a small child. However, until the advent of digital cameras my output was very limited, mainly because I was concerned about wasting precious film. Nowadays I can instantly review my images on the back screen of my digital camera, delete the bad ones and, if my subject(s) is still around, take more photographs, correcting for exposure, depth of field etc. all the time. Suddenly wildlife photography has become much easier both for me and for millions of others around the world.

After I started OCA course work in 2007 I began to realise that there was more to learn about photography than simply improving techniques in order to produce better pictures. Photography had become integrated within the world of art and major photography exhibitions were appearing with increasing regularity in London. Very slowly I started to understand that producing aesthetically pleasing images did not guarantee recognition, particularly within the art world. Partly in order to broaden my horizons I dabbled in other areas of photography, in particular the use of reflections to create abstract images. I joined the London Independent Photographic Society (LIPS) for a couple of years and made a substantial effort to understand the photography that appeared in their monthly magazines and annual exhibitions. However, I never got to appreciate or understand the value of much of the work; nor did I find it aesthetically appealing. Without realising it at the time, what I was looking at was concept-driven photographic art. Eventually I gave up trying to connect with the work of other LIPS members and left.

Further down the line in my OCA course work I started to understand, by virtue of research and project work, more about the theory and practice of photographic art and to appreciate why there was more to images (or portfolios of images) that I had been studying than simple aesthetic appeal, which was often lacking. Understanding the background to the work helped me to appreciate the images more, although many still left me cold. I tried to connect my own wildlife photography to this work: I failed! Wildlife images may be popular and appealing, but they seemed as different to photographic art as chalk is to cheese.


Whilst I occasionally tried to integrate my wildlife photography into the OCA course work at levels 1 and 2 I put most of my effort into improving technique, investigating other genres in which I was interested (in particular landscape photography, documentary and photo-collage) and learning more about the history of and theory behind movements in photographic art. However, the current course offered more freedom to express myself and I decided to return to my main interest and carry out a major project with a conceptual theme (“why we feed wild birds”) within the genres of wildlife and documentary photography. A natural topic for the critical essay was therefore to look at the relationship (if any) between wildlife photography and photographic art: not only would this give me a better understanding of how to produce a concept-driven portfolio but also it would give me the opportunity to channel the frustration that I, as a wildlife photographer, had felt about the lack of interest shown in this genre by the art world, into a piece of writing.

 I concentrated initially on the relationship between the genre of wildlife photography and the world of photographic art. I was fortunate that as I was starting to put together my ideas I noticed a forum on the OCA web site:

The forum discussed the relationship of wildlife photography with photographic art, other genres and OCA course content. Although I found much of the discussion simplistic and superficial (understandably, given the medium) and I disagreed with some of the comments I was encouraged by the fact that some of the contributors were similarly frustrated by the apparent dismissal of wildlife photography in the artistic media and by being unable to express their interest in wildlife photography through their course work. The forum also reinforced my view that the very different attitude to the genre of landscape photography by the art establishment must be the key to understanding why wildlife photography has become isolated and this encouraged me to dig deeper into the reasons for the very different treatment of these genres.

 I had come into contact with the work of Daniel Beltrá and other “wildlife photojournalists” through my regular visits to the “Wildlife Photographer of the Year” and “Sony World Photography Awards” exhibitions and felt that their work provided an important link between the genres of wildlife photography, documentary and photojournalism. Whilst this does not provide a link with the creative arts it does both highlight a connection between wildlife photography and other genres and suggests a potentially important role for the genre. I had originally planned to give Daniel Beltrá’s work more prominence in the essay. However his output, whilst important to the flow of my argument, is still fairly limited so I decided to restrict myself to commenting in detail on a single portfolio of his work.

The research to find a connection between wildlife photography and photographic art sent me in some fascinating directions. Whilst I ultimately failed to find a clear solution that might integrate these areas I did establish (in my own mind, at least) why the genre of landscape photography has become accepted by the photographic art establishment, whilst the genre of wildlife photography has not. I am convinced now that the differences between these two genres explain why wildlife photography occupies its current niche.

The essay was started in March 2014, but the majority was written between May and early August, with breaks for holidays. Because of my interest in the subject matter I found it easy to write an initial draft. The main problem was in giving prominence to answering the various questions and issues raised in the introduction. I decided to write objectively, to provide a relatively impartial view (c.f. Project 5) of the subject. Despite being in love with wildlife photography I found that it was not too difficult to comprehend why there is so little interaction between this genre and the photographic art establishment, why it differs from the genre of landscape photography and hence why it occupies its current role. Of course I may be mistaken, but the review aims to understand the genre, its status and its interaction with other genres. It is not a polemic about the way wildlife photography has been unfairly treated!

I have consciously avoided mentioning specific wildlife photographers (other than the photojournalists), because I felt that discussing their (figurative) work would not add anything to the debate. Perhaps my essay is skewed a little towards understanding the role of landscape photography in the development of photographic art, but I felt that this was important in explaining why the differences between this genre and that of wildlife photography help us to understand why the latter is largely ignored by the art establishment.

Final Comments

When I started writing the essay I felt hopeful that I could find a role for wildlife photography within the art establishment. With the essay finished I now realise how hard it will be for the genre to establish a foothold! However, I do have a much greater understanding of why the worlds of the wildlife photographer and the art establishment show so little overlap. I hope that my major project will explore some of the areas of overlap.

 I do believe that wildlife photography has an important role to play, both in inspiring more people to interact with nature and in bringing the attention of the world to the way that man is destroying the natural world. The total destruction of our environment and the wildlife that goes with it will leave little hope for the future of mankind. Wildlife photography will disappear, but so will other photographic genres. Wildlife photography may not be art, but it is important!

"Stranger Than Fiction": Joan Fontcuberta, Science Museum, London

Joan Fontcuberta (b 1955) is a Catalan photographer and artist, whose works straddle the boundary between photographic truth and fiction. This, his first major UK exhibition, features six of his best-known works spanning nearly 20 years. Each work is, in every sense, a fabrication: a more or less convincing lie. As such, the works explore issues such as the power of the apparently objective photograph as evidence and the balance between our spiritual wish to believe and our logic-driven scepticism.

On entering the Media Space gallery we are confronted with Fontcuberta’s best known work: “Fauna” (1987). Produced in collaboration with artist and writer Pere Formiguera (1952-2013), the work purports to document the archive of the life’s work of the mysterious late Professor Peter Ameisenhaufen, discovered by the artists in the basement of a B&B in northern Scotland. The archive features “zoological discoveries” made by Ameisenhaufen on his worldwide expeditions, which appear to be exceptions to Darwin’s theory of evolution. The “discoveries” include a monkey with wings and a unicorn horn, a snake with twelve legs and a two-legged hybrid of a fox and a turtle (Image). Not content with providing photographs, “taken in the field”, of these monstrosities, the artists include sketches, extracts from contemporary notebooks, stuffed animals, X-rays and even vocalisations of selected exhibits: indeed, everything one would expect from a display in the Natural History Museum, just up the road.


Image: Joan Fontcuberta

There is no doubt today that this work is a very elaborate hoax, but when it was exhibited in Barcelona in 1989 apparently 30% of university educated visitors aged 20-30 believed that some of these creatures could have existed. Knowing the history behind the project, I found reading the notes and looking at the photographs to be an amusing and enjoyable experience.

The genesis of “Fauna” is suggested by studying the earlier (1984) work: “Herbarium”. Here, Fontcuberta presents an array of photographs of “new plant discoveries” which are, in reality, composed of a mixture of plant matter and various man-made materials. Later works include “Constellations” (1993), a series of prints purporting to be night sky views of star constellations but which are actually made from the traces of insects, dust and dirt that gathered on photographic paper on the window of his car as he drove to and from work. “Orogenesis” (2002) features prints of entirely mythical, computer generated landscapes produced by using a program to convert map contours into three dimensional landscape images. The contours have in turn been generated by digitally scanning old photographs as well as paintings by artists such as Cezanne and Turner.

Fontcuberta returned to the subject of mythical beasts with “Sirens” (2000), a series of photographs apparently depicting fossilised evidence for “Hydropithecus Alpinus”, a mermaid-type creation with human features. He collaborated with a local museum to produce the “fossils” and place them at a location in the French Alps where, as far as I am aware, they can still be viewed today. For this work Fontcuberta assumed the role of Father Jean Fontana, the “discoverer” of the fossils, whose photograph appears alongside some of the exhibits. This hoax proved too much for some and produced an angry response, in particular from teachers who argued that “amending” the fossil record in this way would confuse their pupils. Perhaps in the light of this the final work on display, “Karelia, Miracles and Co” (2002) is a very funny photographic record of miracles such as walking on water and “dolphin surfing” performed by monks (who look very much like Fontcuberta himself) at a monastery in Karelia, the region of northern Europe that straddles Russia and Finland. Anybody who believes that these photographs are for real definitely needs their head examining!

Conclusions
Delving more deeply into the works on display it is possible to see various common themes, the most obvious being the use of the supposedly objective medium of photography to practice deception: can we believe what we see in any photograph? Are the exhibits that we see in London’s museums genuine and, if so, how can we prove that they are? Nowadays we are used to seeing images that have clearly been doctored but in the 1980s, before the digital era, it is easy to see why the public might possibly have been convinced by the data presented in the “Fauna” exhibition. Now that Fontcuberta has been well and truly exposed as a hoaxer his works continue to amuse and entertain, but have lost some of their power to question perception because today's public is far more sceptical of what it sees in the media than it has ever been.
The Science Museum charges a fee (£8.00 for an adult) to visit this exhibition. In my view this is well worthwhile, despite the fact that the layout of the exhibition space makes it very difficult to work through the exhibition in a logical order. Also, the lighting is generally inadequate (both problems were also apparent on my visit to an earlier exhibition here by Tony Ray-Jones and Martin Parr). This is a rare opportunity to enjoy the work of a photographer whose unique blend of creative ideas and universal humour produces an enjoyable, if artificial experience. Suspend disbelief and visit!

Friday, 11 July 2014

Red Kites at Gigrin Farm

On 20 June 2014 I paid my second visit of the year to the red kite feeding station at Gigrin Farm, near Rhayader in mid Wales, looking for images for my major project portfolio on feeding wild birds and the reasons why we feed them. Red kites are fed meat at Gigrin every day of the year, at exactly the same time of day (2.00 pm GMT or 3.00 pm BST). The meat is claimed to be too good for human consumption (!!) and it attracts up to 500 kites from all over the region: the sky seems to be filled with kites! Gigrin ticks quite a few of the boxes as to why we feed wild birds. Firstly it is a commercial enterprise (I paid £17.00 for the privilege of using an elevated photography hide with open views, although an afternoon in a public hide costs £5.00) and a selection of merchandise is available (I have three polo shirts in different colours in my collection!). Secondly the supplementary feeding station has been important in conserving and then increasing the population of this majestic bird in Wales after it had been reduced to a handful of individuals by the 1970s. Injured birds are nursed back to health here in a rehabilitation centre and, where possible, released back into the wild. Thirdly, it gives children an opportunity to see majestic birds of prey at close quarters and hopefully inspire them to love and respect nature. Finally, it offers unrivalled opportunities for wildlife photographers to photograph the birds in action at very close quarters.


I have been to Gigrin many times before and have recorded thousands of images of the birds in flight (they hardly ever land on the ground, preferring to fly low and seize food items with their talons). On this occasion I wanted to capture the entire feeding sequence and, in particular, to photograph the birds eating in flight. I knew from past experience that I had set myself a challenging target. Three hours and 800+ images (captured using the Nikon D7000 with 70-300mm zoom and 300mm f4 prime lenses) later I called it a day and completed the 420 mile round trip to my home. A lengthy session of “post production” resulted in just 40 edited images being retained. Whether any of these will reach the final portfolio remains to be seen, but the following montage (Image; reading across and then down from top left to bottom right) gives a summary of the various feeding “events”, from the time the meat is put out to the moment that a kite swallows its last morsel of meat.


Image: Red Kites at Gigrin, 20 June 2014

Monday, 16 June 2014

Henry Moore at Perry Green (Visited 25 May 2014)

My partner and I spent a pleasant afternoon wandering around Henry Moore’s house and grounds in the village of Perry Green, which is about a 30 minute drive from where I live in Royston. Both are open to the public: we have visited before, but timed our visit this time to coincide with an exhibition of the work of other artists and sculptors who have been influenced by Moore. Damien Hirst’s “pickled cows” were on display and it was interesting to note that at one point in his career Moore and his work were criticised and lampooned by other artists who felt that he was the “golden boy” of the establishment and that others were not getting a “look in”.


I always take a camera on these visits and try to look for novel subjects for the lens. Obviously just photographing Moore’s sculptures is of little value, so I looked to investigate the “inner space” of his works, concentrating on shape, pattern, colour and texture. I liked and kept half a dozen of the resultant images. One in particular caught my eye (Image): the combination of ovals and angles, the texture of the bronze and the variety of colour (slightly enhanced in post-production) were aesthetically appealing. I entered an A4 mounted print of the image into Royston Photographic Society’s 2014 “Open Print” competition on 12 June 2014. Much to my surprise, it received top marks and won the certificate for the judge’s favourite print of the competition (out of 55 entered)!

Image

How valid as a work of art is a photograph of a work of art? I enjoy this image purely as an abstract, just as I would an abstract created by focussing on a detail of a piece of engineering, such as a bridge or a clock mechanism, or focussing on a detail created by nature, such as ripples in the sand or rock strata. Sometimes man and nature combine (reflections of light on a canal spring to mind) to give the photographer the opportunity to create their abstract: in my view, all are equally valid.

Andreas Gursky at the White Cube

Andreas Gursky (b 1955) is known for his huge, interior and exterior landscape photographic works, which are incredibly rich in detail. The photographs, often taken from an elevated viewpoint, are taken with a large format camera. His works sell at auction for huge, record-breaking amounts of money. The White Cube exhibition, his first in London since 2007, features some of his more recent works including the very recent (2013-14) “Super Hero” works and “Lehmbruck I and II”, that have not to my knowledge been exhibited before.

The White Cube is an excellent venue for exhibiting Gursky’s work. The large rooms, plain white walls and functional design of the gallery space compliment the huge (up to 2.5 x 5 metre) framed prints and allow the visitor plenty of opportunity to contemplate the incredible detail in the works.


Viewing Gursky’s art at close quarters enables the visitor to appreciate just what it is that excites dealers and collectors to pay huge amounts of money for his works. Prints such as “Kirchentag” and “May Day IV”, which depict mass festival gatherings in Germany, depict ant-like figures within a huge crowd, enabling the viewer to study both the connections between individuals and the way in which they integrate to produce crowd activity. In contrast, “Lehmbruck I” and “Lehmbruck II” create tension by presenting a conundrum in the form of the distinctive architecture of this Duisburg museum, used as a setting for a selection of iconic works of art together with an apparent audience of a small number of carefully placed figures (see below). I imagine that a huge amount of time and effort must have gone into post-production in order to finish these works, but I found it hard to tear my eyes away from them and move on; a pointer to their efficacy, at least for this spectator.

Andreas Gursky: "Lehmbruck I"

Also on display for the first time is a new series of images inspired by Hollywood comic-book heroes, such as Spider-Man, in which the heroes are placed in idealised landscapes. These works have provoked a little copyright controversy (which will doubtless renew the phrase that “there is no such thing as bad publicity”, although I found this section of the exhibition less thought-provoking than others.

Two of the reflections of neon lights on the waters of the Chao Phraya River from Gursky’s “Bangkok” series are featured here. I have the book, but looking at the huge prints on the walls is an altogether more satisfying experience than thumbing through them in the book. The beautiful abstract, colourful shapes and patterns caused by the effects of the neon lights on the swirling waters are really effective and the individual items of human debris being carried downriver all add to the overall pattern (In my own work with reflections on canals and slow-moving water, such items are usually removed in post-production: I wonder whether, in Gursky’s images, some items of debris have actually been added in post-production to give the images more balance….).

I really enjoy looking at works of art that challenge the viewer to interpret their meaning so “Lager”, which incorporates parts of some of his other works within a very three dimensional, architectural setting, was a firm favourite.

Viewing Gursky’s full sized photographic prints enabled me to appreciate just why he has become so popular amongst rich collectors of fine art. The scale, the incredible detail afforded by the use of a large format camera, the clever choice of subject matter and the (doubtless) huge amount of post-production work that went into the assembly of each work on display here all lead to the production of objects that both have an immediate impact, are aesthetically appealing and will constantly reveal more with each viewing. Although there is a consistent style to his work, the variety of Gursky’s subject matter is impressive.

Learning Points, Future Work and References
Many of Gursky’s works challenge the viewer to interpret their meaning, but all can be enjoyed as aesthetically appealing works of art. Presenting the viewer with an image (or series of images) that presents a visual conundrum or encourages them to create their own story from the image(s) creates tension and must add value to the art. This will be particularly relevant to my own major project work and I should look to create tension within the story board. Whilst it is not possible to know how much digital manipulation was applied to each of Gursky’s images, some of these works clearly exemplify how the sophisticated tailoring of post-production techniques can produce an aesthetically appealing effect. On an inevitably simpler scale, I could (and occasionally do) apply similar techniques to my own work.


Wednesday, 4 June 2014

Project 9: Change. Studies of Leaf Decay

Project 9: Change. Studies of Leaf Decay.

Shortly after receiving the notes for the current course in September 2013 I decided to initiate a personal project, looking at leaf decay. The intention was to study the decay, over weeks, of fallen leaves. I was particularly interested in looking for colour changes caused by the chemical degradation of the chlorophyll porphyrins that give the leaves their colour and in comparing the degradation of leaves from different species of tree. I planned to photograph the leaves at regular intervals and to use the photographs to produce composite images, tracking the progress of the decay. Although I set myself a number of goals, one goal was to produce and present a sequence of images for Project 9 (“Change”) of the course work.

Following the telephone discussion with my tutor, held in December 2013, it was agreed that all my course project work for Assignments 1 and 2 should be geared to complimenting and benefiting the study for my major project (“Feeding The Birds”). Consequently, the leaf decay studies were considered unsuitable. However, the work was not abandoned and I have included an overview of the studies to date here, as part of my logbook/blog.

 Methodology
Freshly fallen leaves were collected between late October and early November. Leaves from a wide variety of tree species were chosen. The main criteria for collection were that (a) the collected leaves should be colourful, with at least three different colours (including green) being visible at the start and (b) they should incorporate distinctive forms, patterns and/or defects that could be studied as the leaves decayed.

The leaves were photographed on the day of collection. They were then left outdoors, at the mercy of the elements, to “weather”. The leaves were then re-photographed every 2-4 days until no significant changes could be seen between the final two images. Photography was carried out by placing the individual leaves on a light box, after the leaves were first dampened (if necessary) and then flattened inside a heavy book. All leaves were placed diagonally across the light box, with the stem at the bottom right. Care was taken to ensure that the leaves were always the right way up! The camera (always the Nikon D90 for this project) was adjusted manually, with the 17-70mm zoom lens set to ca 35mm, the shutter speed between 1/40 and 1/60 seconds and the aperture in the range f8 to f11 (as leaves darkened it was necessary to use longer shutter speeds and/or wider apertures).

I started photographing 15 leaves, but only ended with seven. Some of the leaves, despite being pinned down outside by bricks and stones, blew away in the storm force winds of the “St Jude’s Storm”. Other leaves produced uninteresting results, so these were discarded.

Post-production work involved selecting (say) five from up to 12 images of an individual leaf, which together clearly showed the progress of decay. Each image was then cropped in a horizontal (7x5) format, using “Photoshop Elements 8”. Blemishes on the surface of the light box were removed and the five images were roughly “equalised” for light box brightness. Images were reduced to a standard size, care being taken to ensure that the size of the leaf in each image was essentially the same. Minor changes were made to leaf brightness and contrast. The leaf in each image was then selected and copied onto a plain white background. The leaf was rotated into a vertical position (stem at the bottom). The resultant image was then cropped closely to each side of the leaf, the cropped image (now in “portrait” orientation) being adjusted to a standard height. Finally, the leaves in each of the five images were again selected and copied onto a “letterbox” shaped plain white background and moved so that the first photograph of the leaf was on the left and the last photograph was on the right, with the leaves in date sequence and similar gaps between each two leaves. The progress of decay could then be studied by moving sequentially from left to right.

The composite images for oak leaf (Image 1), maple leaf (Image 2) and beech leaf (Image 3) decay are shown below.

Image 1: Oak Leaf Decay


Image 2: Maple Leaf Decay

Image 3: Beech Leaf Decay

I decided to have Images 1 and 3 printed commercially at (20x8) inch size. The prints reveal more clearly the subtle effects of decay moving from the left to the right of each sequence. However, they also demonstrate that the beautiful changes in colour experienced when leaves “turn” in the autumn whilst still attached to the trees (particularly noticeable in Japanese Maple) cannot be reproduced once the leaf has fallen; rather, the leaves just darken and turn brown as the tree that has nurtured them can no longer provide any sustenance.

Further Work
From collecting the leaves to producing the photographs and converting them into composite images, this project has consumed a considerable amount of time (only a fraction of the work is presented here). However, the project is unfinished. I have presented the results of leaf decay in a formal, figurative manner. Although this is an effective way of illustrating how an individual leaf decays I would like to go further by producing a composite for leaf decay in general, in which the destinies of all the leaves involved in my study are interwoven. When (if ever!) there is time I have an idea in my head about how to put across the concept of (fallen) leaf decay, using images of all the leaves that I studied, in a more abstract and artistic manner….. watch this space.



Assignment 2 Project 3: Modification of a High Key Image

In general, my tutor’s feedback regarding the two high key and two low key images of birds that I had submitted for Project 3 of my second assignment was positive. The most dynamic image of the set was a high key study of juvenile whooper swans landing (Image 1 below; presented here with a narrow black border). Whilst I was generally happy with the outcome of my post-production work I was a little unhappy with the ordering of the swans: the one in the middle, which is already skimming the surface of the water with its feet, should really be “leading the way” at the front! Also, despite the “letterbox” cropping, the photograph does not give the birds quite enough space to move into.

Image 1

My tutor pointed out that, with such a simple background, it would have been fairly easy to re-position the swans in the required order. The only issue that I have with this is that I like to record natural events as truthfully as possible and, although I am not averse to removing distracting objects that do not affect the natural history story presented in the image, changing the order of the birds is not something I would consider if I was presenting this image in competition or using it for commercial purposes. However, since neither of these considerations applies here…….

The image was edited in “Photoshop Elements 8”, using the Clone Stamp tool to remove the left hand swan and then to replace it by moving the central swan over to the left hand side of the image. The resultant image (featuring two swans, with a large central gap between them) was saved. The first image was re-opened. This time the central swan was removed using the Clone Stamp tool and the left hand swan was moved into the centre of the frame. The resultant image was pasted over the first modified image to create a separate (top) layer. The section to the left of the (new) central swan was erased to reveal the “skimming” swan and the resultant image was flattened. Finally, the few strands of remaining vegetation (top right of Image 1) were erased to give a cleaner image (Image 2), featuring the new, improved line-up of swans.

Image 2

Finally, I made two further modifications. Firstly I slightly extended the background to the left of the swans, to give them more space to fly/swim into, cropping off an equivalent area on the right of the image. Then, I reversed the image horizontally so that the action was taking place from left to right. This is the direction that my gaze naturally tends to follow when I am “reading” an image, perhaps because I also read from left to right, and produces what for me is a more natural looking image. The whole process, from starting with the original image to producing the final image (Image 3), took just 20 minutes.

Image 3

Conclusions and Key Learning Points
Whilst Image 3 is “manufactured” it does provide a fluent, ordered illustration of some of the stages of swans landing and reads smoothly as a simple “action” story as the eye moves from left to right. The resultant sequence is now more aesthetically pleasing, although it could be argued that it loses some of the tension of the original.

Learning Points:
·         When a “good” image has been produced it is worthwhile thinking about whether and, if so, how it can be made even better during post-production.

·         High key images offer more potential for modification of the type shown above than do those images that have been produced and/or processed using a standard exposure.

·   In creatively modifying an image in post-production, the balances between aesthetics, tension and photographic truth are critical considerations.